First Conversations with Kids About RaceAsk the Transracial Parenting Expertby Deborah Johnson
Q. I want my child to be able to handle racism when he’s older. What’s the best way to prepare him?
A. Instead of waiting until your child is confused or hurt by racism, begin by having conversations about physical and ethnic differences when he’s two-and-a-half or three years old. What color hair does Mommy have? What shape eyes do you have? What about our neighbor? Who has freckles? Get your child to use very specific descriptive language—“Jody has really curly hair and brown skin, and Mark has straight blond hair and green eyes.” This lets him know that it’s fun and perfectly acceptable to notice and explore differences.
You can also talk about why people look the way they do—explain that there’s a geographical connection to physical and ethnic characteristics.
Teachable moments Talking about race might feel awkward, but it’s how kids learn how to think about differences. I remember being with my son, who was three years old at the time, when he pointed at a man wearing a turban. “Look, mom, a genie,” he said, loudly. A perfect teachable moment—only I needed to first talk him down off the table he was standing on. You don’t want to reprimand or shush children in such situations; that sends the message that talking about differences is bad. When my son was back on the floor, I turned his comment around by affirming that he noticed the difference: “Isn’t that an interesting hat? It’s wonderful that you noticed it.” Then you can shift to an explanation: “Let’s talk about the different types of head coverings that people wear. He’s not a genie, but he wears a special hat because of his religion.”
Another time, I was with a preschool-aged client who saw a girl with dark skin and asked, “She looks dirty. Do you think she needs a bath?” Questions like this make you wince, but you can turn them around and help a child understand what he’s seeing: “Hmm, I don’t think so, but isn’t she lucky? She has such beautiful dark skin.” Of course, if it’s an awkward time to talk, you can postpone the conversation by saying, “I’m really glad you asked that, but we need to be quiet in church. We can talk about it later.”
Talking with older kids Jumping right into a discussion about racism with older kids can seem uncomfortable, but there are ways to approach it. Say something like, “You know, I was talking to Sarah’s mom, and she told me that Sarah was teased about being Chinese. You and I have never really talked about the ways in which people are different. I’m sorry about that. I think it’s really important.” Admit that racial differences can be difficult to talk about and then say, “I don’t want you to feel that you wouldn’t have anyone to talk to if you experienced what Sarah did. If something like that happens, I hope that you know you can share it with me.”
After that conversation, go back to the earlier strategy of noticing differences with your child. You can be upfront about it with older kids: “You know, we haven’t explored different cultures and I feel bad about that. This is a really important part of growing our family’s understanding of these issues. On Saturday, we should go to the culture festival downtown and see what we can learn.”
Let your child know you’re being strategic—we’ve been remiss, now we’re going to go back and fix it. Talking through these steps is crucial; it will help you build a strong foundation for explaining a far more difficult topic: racism.
Deborah Johnson is a Minneapolis-based social worker with 25 years of experience working with adoptive families, and an adult adoptee from Korea. Share conversations you've had with your kids about race or racism in the Transracial Families Group on AdoptiveFamiliesCircle
Back To Home Page ©2013 Adoptive Families. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part is prohibited. |
Comments
I have always taught my two kids (both from South Korea) that people come in all shapes, sizes and colors, because that was God's intention. I have repeated that statement many times over the years, each time that I hear them make a comment about how someone looks different.
Posted by: Jackie Price at 9:58am Jun 9
I definitely think that living your life does provide wonderful teaching moments. But how do you handle it when your 5 year old says he hates himself because his skin doesn't look like mine. Or that he isn't cool, because of his skin color.
Posted by: Tricia Boudreaux at 10:06am Sep 23
Going downtown to the culture festival is a wonderful idea, when there is one. Most of us live in cities that have one "festival" a year, and the conversation usually happens three months later! Try reading books or watching age appropriate movies... both are easier to have around at just the right moment.
Posted by: gbb at 1:39pm Sep 23
I think this article is fine, but I find it a little disconcerting that the assumption is that families have somehow been remiss in dealing with this topic! (And frankly, my guess is that any family that has been ignoring it isn't suddenly going to be interested in fixing it.)
Posted by: j, at 7:47am Oct 6
To Tricia: I have a 3 year old that doesn't match my skin or my 5 year old's skin (both came to our family through adoption). My 5 year old has told me multiple times that he wants his brother to match him/us. Also, my 3 year old has commented about not having anyone that he matches in our family (yes, even at 3). My response to that is, "I wish we matched too...But we don't and that's ok. We are still a family and God made us all to look exactly how he wanted us and he put our family together exactly how he wanted it." Of course, I always reinforce how beautiful they each are individually also. Sharing in their feelings that our skin doesn't match our connection inside is ok. In addition, I find ways for the boys to match (Pajamas, etc.) and point out ways they do match (both have brown eyes, etc.). Just some ideas.
Posted by: Andrea S. at 1:25pm Oct 6
My biracial daughter has gorgeous light brown skin, a few shades darker than my own olive complexion. I've tried to instill in her a pride in her skin color. We talk about how there are people who actually 'pay' to achieve the skin color she was born with! (i.e. - at tanning salons.) At age 6 or 7, she once rolled up her sleeve, placed her arm next to mine - and quipped "Hey, mom, you got to catch up!"
Posted by: Diane D at 7:15am Mar 24
Post a comment